Ever felt that Lismore’s sealed road network was not up to scratch?
Well now it’s official.
Astonishing as it may seem, for the first time ever Lismore Council now knows what it should be spending to maintain its sealed road network.
Consultants employed by Council two years ago examined our sealed roads and concluded that we need to spend $7.3 million a year just to keep it in a satisfactory state.
Council currently spends $5.1 million.The $2.2 million shortfall, reported to a council workshop earlier this month, confirms what some of us have been saying for years: That our roads are dangerously under-funded.
Unfortunately the required $7.3 million will grow each year as costs increase. Unless the problem is addressed, the network will continue to worsen.
In addition the consultants found that there was a backlog of road works - where roads were less than satisfactory - amounting to $79 million!
The challenge for Council is to increase road funding by $2.2 million a year and develop a way to address the huge backlog.On top of this, additional money has to be set aside to improve and expand the network.
To date Council has shown no inclination to address the problem.
The attitude of many Councillors is that the problem is too big to tackle.
However other councils with similar problems have developed strategies and made maintaining their road system a top priority. Lismore Councillors need to recognise their responsibilities as stewards of the community’s essential assets, reorder Council priorities, call a halt to new capital works and examine its current spending.
Gravel Roads – funding cut by 30 per cent
Lismore has 400km of gravel roads – more than one third of the total road network.
Judging by the number of complaints we have received they are obviously in an atrocious condition.
It’s easy to blame the wet weather for their condition – they tend to crumble at the first whiff of rain. But this is only a small part of the story.
Despite protests from groups all over the Council area and surveys showing only 18 per cent of rural residents think rural roads are reasonable, there has been no increase in gravel road funding for many years.
However costs have been rising rapidly: by five or six per cent a year for the past ten years.In 2001 Council allocated $1 million for maintaining gravel roads.
This year, and in all the intervening years, the amount allocated was unchanged at $1 million.
Yet costs have risen by more than 30 per cent since then.
You don’t have to be a genius to forecast the result.
Service levels on gravel roads have had to be slashed.
In this year alone grading work will have to be cut by 16 per cent and gravel re-sheeting by 20 per cent.This is a great disappointment because Council several years ago improved its service levels by agreeing to grade busy gravel roads three times a year (up from once a year) and give less travelled roads an extra grade (depending on traffic volume and condition).
We are now going backwards.
The only good news here is that flood money from the State Government will mean a once-off allocation for gravel roads this year.
This money is to repair the damage caused by the flood and to bring the roads back to the condition they were in before it occurred.
There will be a temporary improvement but the longer term outlook is bleak unless Council allocates more money.
Council needs to be watched
As you hear about new Council initiatives, keep in mind one important point that most of our Councillors and staff seem to have forgotten.The State Government only allows councils to increase their income by the rate pegging figure handed down each year.
Normally it is around three per cent or slightly above.
By design this only represents enough to cover Council’s annual increase in costs .
What it means is that councils are only allowed enough to keep current services going and not much more.Consequently any major projects have to come at the expense of existing services
If Council wants extra rate income it has to make an application to the State Government for a special rate rise.
Lismore has not done this for many years.
However, over the past few years Lismore Council has gone on a spending spree, investing in new assets such as swimming pools, beautification works and recreation centres.
These investments not only cost ratepayers in terms of the cost of building them but in the ongoing costs of maintenance and trading losses.As mentioned elsewhere, outdoor activities (roads, parks, sporting grounds etc) have been squeezed continuously to give scope for these new spending initiatives.
Alarmingly, new spending is still being planned – the takeover of the Lismore Show Ground and its failing infrastructure, a new art gallery and cultural precinct, a homeless shelter and the beautification of Woodlark Street.
All worthy undertakings – but they should not be at the expense of existing infrastructure.
A lot of money has been invested in our existing assets and they should not be allowed to run down.
Cultural Centre hits funding wall
Lismore Council has had to scale back its grand plan for a cultural precinct in the CBD following its failure to attract State or Federal Government funding.
The original plan was for a $12 million iconic art gallery, to be named after artist Margaret Olley, on the former Lismore High School site fronting onto Keen Street.
Together with artist studios, coffee shops, the library, some type of residential space and a commercial sector, the site was planned to be a $70 million cultural precinct that would build on Lismore’s artistic strengths, attract tourism and revitalize the struggling CBD.
It was a grand plan indeed.However the failure to attract funding has prompted some within council to seek to scale back the art gallery component to a more modest $4 million with some assistance from private benefactors.
Will it be iconic and if not, will it actually do what the supporters say it will?
And why is there no funding despite the Federal election and a government brimming with money?
Apparently Labor Party local polling prior to the election detected little public support for the project, so no promises were made.Polling by Lismore City Council revealed a similar sentiment. In a resident satisfaction survey carried out by Council last year, 85 per cent said they wanted Council to either spend the same or less than they currently do on the art gallery. Only 15 per cent wanted it increased.
In addition some 57 per cent of respondents said they had not used the gallery in the last year and 25 per cent said they had visited only once or twice.
Given this lack of support and much higher priorities elsewhere it is probably time to put the project on hold until more funding becomes available.
With the next budget starting in deficit and a huge backlog of infrastructure works, there is no money available.
Even if all the funds were borrowed, repayments would be of the order of $400,000 a year plus depreciation and running costs.
My suggestion is to wait, obtain outside funding, build public support if possible and then do it properly.
Lismore Acquatic Centre budget blues
The $17 million Lismore Sports and Aquatic Centre, known to most of us as the Goonellabah Recreation Centre, is suffering from a $1.1 million budget blowout .The cost blowouts have been caused by a rock bed under the site, water recycling issues and other unexpected costs.
These add up to a net $400,000.Worse still, the new Federal Government is reviewing the Regional Partnership Scheme under which Lismore was to receive a grant of $638,000. This is now in doubt.
Apparently all the documents were not signed at the time of the election. So now we are more than$1 million behind. The centre is due to open in December. We don’t yet know what to do about the finances. Borrow even more probably.
Editorial
Welcome to Inside Lismore.
This modest publication used to be known as the Lismore Council Chronicle but the name change was brought in to avoid confusion.
THIS IS NOT an official Council publication – far from it. It’s an attempt to bring a different view as to what is going on in Lismore City council – warts and all.
Not that everything is bad – it is just that it could be much better. The biggest problem in my view is that Council has stopped listening to residents and ratepayers.
We know what they want. Council just has other ideas. We pay lip service to consultation but are reluctant to follow this through.We see it at McLean’s Ridges where residents are practically unanimous in their opposition to high density, urban type development in their area.
We see it in Dunoon where the same development problem exists.
We see it in the way Council allocates its budget.
More than 80 per cent of residents want us to spend more on roads yet every year we spend less in real terms.
It seems to me that there are two views on being a Councillor.
One is that you are elected to make decisions.
This is the “trust me” model. “If you don’t like what I do, don’t reelect me.” The other model is where local government can excel.
Here Councillors are in constant contact with their community and make decisions after listening to their views.
It means constant meaningful consultation.
This approach is more time consuming and often difficult, particularly where the community is divided.
But where Council has done it properly, taken the time and fully informed the community, in the overwhelming majority of cases the community will accept the decision – even if not everyone agrees. In short Councillors have no monopoly on knowledge or wisdom.
Climate change – a start but more to do
Lismore Council has set a target to reduce its greenhouse gas emissions by 20 per cent in 2012.
To do this a $1 million revolving fund has been established to finance measures that have a measurable payback period.
While this sounds great and does represent a start, the measures that will be taken are those that should have been taken even without a greenhouse problem.
It’s just an efficiency thing - such as more efficient street lights.In other words it costs money to change the lights over but the cost is recouped in lower electricity charges.
Much more will have to be done.
But council has other worries. Council’s legal advice is that climate change will have to be built into its entire decision making.
It has to know the risks and take appropriate measures or it can be held legally liable.Already a number of Court cases have resulted in judgements that say Councils are negligent if they have not considered climate change in their actions. This can range from planning issues, the risk of floods, storms and winds, rising sea levels and even road construction.
Potential property buyers for example will have to be warned that their likely purchase may be at risk - or Council could be liable.
Problems appear greater on the coast. Engineers tell us that for every one metre rise in the sea level, erosion will occur up to 100 metres inland.
Sea levels are expected to rise by one metre this century just from the thermal expansion of the sea water.
This does not take into account any rise from melting ice.
Dunoon subdivision on the nose but put on hold
The 50 lot subdivision DA for Dunoon has been put on hold following a last minute re-examination of the proposal by staff.
It was scheduled to go before Lismore Council on May 13 but has now been delayed until the applicant responds to staff and resident objections.
The problem has occurred because the development went outside the area zoned as village and into agricultural land.
This is sometimes allowable, sometimes not.
Staff have now formed the view that it is not.Dunoon residents have been fighting the DA for almost two years now, claiming the density of the development is far too high and that there are huge problems with a proposed sewerage treatment plant (STP).
The latest proposal from the developer – a company associated with Hardie Holdings of Four Corners fame, has made a number of changes including reducing the number of blocks surrounding the Dunoon Sports Club.
But the fundamental objections of the residents remain the same. The STP is just 150 metres from the eastern edge of the village – directly in the path of the prevailing winds and within sight of the village and the Club outdoor dining area.The STP will be owned, operated and funded by the new residents under community title.
So far existing residents have not been told just how this will work, what happens if the STP is not maintained properly and whether or not the STP will be odour and noise free and environmentally acceptable.
The high density of the development, which will increase the size of Dunoon by more than 30 per cent is also a major problem.
People choose to live in a village because of its smaller size and its sense of community.
A huge and sudden increase in population can destroy this amenity and the very reason why people live there.
Council budget – big review well overdue
You’re going to hear a lot about Council’s budget over the next few weeks as it grapples with soaring costs, high debt levels and lower service levels.
Council is now in the position where there are no funds for any new projects.
Existing services will have to be trimmed or cut to bring the budget into balance.
In fact the whole process needs review and I am proposing a big one when Council meets on May 13.
We have not had an extensive review for many years.The review would look at all areas of spending to seek cuts and to reprioritise.
New spending initiatives have left our core services under stress. Our consultants tell us we need to spend an additional $2.2 million a year on our sealed road network just to prevent it from becoming worse.
We have cut funding to gravel roads in real terms by more than 30 per cent since 2002.We now have to reduce the amount of work we do on our roads despite 83 per cent of residents requesting us to do more. There is no money to remedy this situation unless cuts are made elsewhere or we increase rates.
Our rates are already high so we have to look at our spending first.
The motion I am putting forward is in line with the recommendations of the Percy Allen report into local government sustainability. It recommends amongst other things, that councils concentrate on core activities, resist the urge to provide new infrastructure and services until it can maintain existing services and that Councils review their current operations and cut some services if necessary.
So you want to be a Councillor?
The next local government elections are not far away – Saturday September 13 to be precise.
In Lismore the election will be for 10 councillors and a directly elected mayor – a total of eleven and one less than currently exists.
At the last election voters approved a proposal to reduce the number of councillors from the current level.A number of people have already indicated they intend to stand and some existing councillors have said they will not seek re-election.
The position of councillor can be rewarding. It gives the opportunity to work for the community and to contribute talents that can enrich the life of residents.
It can however be hard work and time consuming.
If you want to know more, the Department of Local Government is running a free seminar in Lismore to give prospective candidates a run-down of what is involved.It be held at the Lismore Council Chambers in Goonellabah on Friday May 30 from 6pm to 7,30 pm. You need to book in with council staff.
The department has also released a pamphlet entitled Becoming a Councillor which can be downloaded from the department’s web site http://www.dlg.nsw.gov.au/ .
If there are any prospective candidates out there, feel free to contact me and I will give you an idea of what it is like and how much time it takes.
McLean’s Ridges rezoning delayed
The controversial proposal to rezone land in Cameron Road at Mclean’s Ridges has been stopped, at least temporarily, because of problems with a community park.
One of the landowners involved with the rezoning has objected to part of his land being used as a community lot that would service both residents in Cameron’s Road and the nearby rezoning proposal at Roseview Road.Both rezoning proposals have drawn strident opposition from existing residents who say they are high density and fundamentally different to the development that is already there. They say they will damage the amenity and character of the area.
If the rural residential rezoning goes ahead as the developer hopes, McLean’s Ridges will become the largest village in the Lismore local government area.
However it has no facilities apart from an ageing 100 year old hall that has insufficient capacity to cater for the population influx.
From a Council perspective the development could be extremely costly.We know that when large numbers of people move into an area they demand council services such playing fields, parks, playgrounds, pre-schools and better roads.
If these are not supplied by the developer then existing ratepayers will be asked to contribute.
Rural residential development is a low priority with Council for this very reason.
However these areas are listed for possible rezoning in Council’s Rural Housing Strategy despite not being near an area which can provide these services.An urgent review of the RHS is required and it should be done in conjunction with a consultation process that allows existing residents to determine just how they see their community developing in the future.
No comments:
Post a Comment